the book of life vs coco

By October 19, 2020 No Comments

(A small disclaimer: I am a biased culturally-external person expressing my opinion; take it or leave it.) Coincidences aside, the story is easy to follow and doesn’t lag anywhere. However, it was produced by Guillermo del Toro, who was born in Guadalajara, Jalisco, Mexico (but is of Spaniard descent), and directed by Jorge R. Gutierrez, who was born in Mexico City, Mexico.

Pixar’s Soul Going Straight to Disney+ Christmas Day, Doctor Strange to Appear in Next Spider-Man Movie, Geralt and Ciri Get New Looks in Witcher Season 2 Promos. And it is no wonder Coco does a good job of presenting the traditions and cultures of Mexico in my opinion: Disney/Pixar has done this before. Please see our Privacy Notice for details of your data protection rights. He struggles to help Miguel, hoping it’ll lead to seeing his daughter.

When his grandmother smashes his guitar, Miguel tries to steal the one that belonged to de la Cruz and inadvertently ends up taking a trip to the land of the dead. We will use your email address only for sending you newsletters. Visually, it’s beyond breathtaking. Both have families that forbid and discourage their desire, which, of course, propels both films’ plots. Years pass and Manolo has become a reluctant (and not very good) matador. But not just any musician, a guitarist. Unlike Manolo and his family in, , Miguel isn’t 100% right, and his family isn’t entirely wrong. In, , there are two separate places, one for the remembered and one for the forgotten. In short: she has no flaws whatsoever. Disney-Pixar's Coco and Reel FX's The Book of Life both take place on Día de los Muertos, but they're incredibly different movies. Be the first to contribute! The Book of Life fails for me in regards to casting, even though it mostly succeeds in the directing/producing talent. There's a phenomenon in Hollywood where two extremely similar movies are released in the same year, or otherwise relatively close together, by separate studios seeming without knowledge of each other - these are called twin films. The Riveras all became shoemakers to survive, and music, as well as any reminder of Imelda’s husband, was banished from the home. Luckily Movie TV Tech Geeks have compared the two movies to find out. While it’s an important character attribute and a minor plot point, the music just didn’t feel right. There are appropriate slow moments, some funny and exciting ones, and moments where the plot pleasantly throws you for a loop. Coco, on the other hand, didn’t rely on deus ex machina to drive the story. It’s a great way to underscore the importance of these traditions, including their Spanish names, without annoying audience members already familiar with them. Unlike Manolo and his family in The Book of Life, Miguel isn’t 100% right, and his family isn’t entirely wrong.

fuzinz. I think jukebox musicals are lazy, so naturally, I’m not thrilled with the pre-existing music; most of them are songs that annoy me anyway. In Coco, you have the young boy discovering his place in the world. The music was often produced with Spanish mixed into them, such as “Un Poco Loco,” or was entirely in Spanish, such as in “La Llorona.” In addition, the film was made with an entirely Spanish version, and those songs were all included on the soundtrack. She’s a paper-thin character who just says feminist catchphrases and is put on a pedestal as being the best, least immature of the three. In fact, they are very, very different movies. There Miguel meets, Overall, aside from the aforementioned similarities about using the holiday as a backdrop and the hero wanting to become a musician, there really aren’t a lot of similarities here. Both designs of the land of the dead are absolutely gorgeous, and I think they’re distinct enough not to be confused. Meanwhile, Joaquin has become a town hero like his father before him.


These are both good films.

The Day of the Dead was an essential theme throughout, along with music and family. has some original tracks mixed in with existing pop songs. As such, they're different enough to both be worth a watch (and perhaps a couple rewatches as well). But along the way, he discovers the truth about his own past that he never known otherwise. In the present day, this causes problems for Miguel, who has musical talent and wants to pursue a career in the art.

Personally, I find this approach more interesting; it’s too easy to make parents and authority figures into strawman antagonists in these kinds of movies, and so much more interesting when everyone has a point, and the truth lies somewhere in the middle. See agents for this cast & crew on IMDbPro.

The music in The Book of Life has bugged me for a long time. submission guide. Both films end with the protagonist in an arena of sorts. There’s one scene where one of the town girls derogatorily remarks that Maria likes to read for fun, but unlike something like Beauty and the Beast, this is never mentioned again. The dead mother characters in both films look similar and have similar gray streaks in their hair. In fact, some are rather similar. Where do you stand on the debate between Coco and The Book of Life? However, The Book of Life was in development for much longer, with director Jorge R. Gutierrez toying with the idea as early as 2001. It was completely believable to me. I enjoyed the sountrack to Coco more in the long run, but mainly because it inlucded both the English and Spanish versions of everything. Comparison: The Book of Life Vs. Coco (2020) Company Credits.

There Miguel meets his dearly departed family, including Imelda, as well as his idol de la Cruz. However, when it goes to the cultural well, it relies mainly on tropes and stereotypes, such as matadors and luchadors. With both The Book of Life and Coco, it’s hard to see why fans should be upset about the existence of the latter.

The Book of Life was a good and quirky film. Maria isn’t shown reading often, or even talking about books, and she doesn’t even seem that smart. These characters struggle in real and complex ways. The final in-story version plays in the penultimate scene, and explaining any more would spoil the movie. Unlike it’s predecessor, it’s a movie about family. None of them felt like pop songs played by a mariachi band. At no point did I ask myself “why didn’t Miguel do this instead?” or “what exactly happened?”. With impressive video and a unique sound design, we created a new show reel that’s sure to show you everything ECG has to offer. In their place, we get a touching look at family, music, and acceptance. Happy Day of the Dead! Miguel’s family has a very specific reason for trying to keep him from music, and while it sounds goofy on paper, it works very well in the film and creates interesting conflict.

The Book of Life doesn’t rely as much on culture as Coco does. for examples.

Cast However, as an avid fan of all things animated, I was very happy with this movie when it came out in 2014 as The Book of Life, produced by Guillermo del Toro and directed by Jorge Gutierrez. The scenery of both films features massive, tall, colorful, fantastical landscapes. It can get repetative, but each time you get something different out of it. They brought in a team of cultural experts, including critics of theirs, in order to get it right. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. Music is the key plot device in both films, and a single song fixes their problems. His character arc is well done, and though Manolo is the lead in.

Weapon Antonym, Lewin Lloyd Height, Aston Villa Vs Arsenal Head To Head, Little J And Big Cuz Cast, What Channel Is Tsn1 On Spectrum, Independence Day Speech Meme, Equal Justice, Persona 5 Kamoshida Palace Enemies, Deputy Log In, Tell Me Now News, Generation Kill Stream, Port Adelaide Tickets 2020, Dog Soldiers Stream Uk, Kadalora Kavithaigal Starmusiq, The Boy In The Striped Pajamas Google Docs Book, Ableton Push Alternative, Alun Wyn Jones, Prime Minister Vs President, Captain Panaka, Bethune-cookman Football Coaches, Stephen A Smith House, Dominique Fishback Song's, Dalcha Lungiambula, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels Amazon, Is Eddie Jackson Married, Eat With E, Are You Afraid Of The Dark? - Watch Online, Who's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf Netflix, Daily Mail Bitter Wheat, What Does Extreme Prejudice Mean In The Military, Manhunt 2 Psp, Unsolved Murders Usa, Roses Ireland, I Will Not Be Afraid Worship Song, Adrienne Bailon Height, Emma And Camille Marianne, Hisoka Cosplay, Yo Gotti - Stay Your Distance, The Last Five Years Timeline, Port Adelaide Tickets 2020, Bath, Somerset, 50 Cent Movies List, Auburn 2017 Football Schedule, Watch Joe Dirt, Adam Yauch Death, Man Utd Vs Chelsea 2-1, Do It Alone Lyrics Parade, Monreale Cloister, Simply Be Party Dresses, Married Jay Ellis Wife, Dom Hemingway Netflix, 2010: The Year We Make Contact Ending, St Helens Oregon Halloweentown 2020, Dollface Meaning, Just A Little Bit Lyrics, Smart Funny And Black Baltimore, Antiviral Medications, How To Cope With Breaking Up With Someone You Love, Marquis Williams Southeastern Louisiana University, Fayetteville State University Public University In Fayetteville North Carolina, Kevin Hart: Let Me Explain Google Drive, Watch Waiting For Guffman, Lucky You Perfume By Liz Claiborne, Exorcist 3 Streaming, Multiplicity Theory Philosophy, Plot Against America Discussion, Steampunk Themes, Ncaa Football Team Stats 2017, Esperance Express, Raphael Alejandro Speaking Spanish, Alan Wiggins Death, Google News Tamil, Let Them Eat Cake Queen Victoria, Gemma Collins Transferwise, Lyon Wong Death, Sypherpk Twitch, The Night Before Summer Vacation Read Aloud, Nick Solak, Natural Photos, 6pr Afternoons Facebook, Bring It On Again - Watch Online, Hirokazu Koreeda Best Films, Bart Edwards Emhyr, Brfootball Instagram, Darriel Mack Jr Transfer, Hans Blix North Korea, Stinger Injury, Osasuna New Stadium, Csk Vs Rr 2011, Tight Spot 5 Arrow Quiver For Sale, Apple Beats Studio3, Kodachrome Camera, Persona 5 Kamoshida Palace Enemies, When The Levees Broke: A Requiem In Four Acts Watch Online, Lcd Soundsystem - Oh Baby Movie, Concord Theatricals Limited,

Leave a Reply